(based on 29 reviews)
of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
Reviewed by 29 customers
Displaying reviews 1-10
Back to top
Previous | Next »
Won't purchase this item
from East Lynn, WV
About Me Avid Cook
Comments about Aluminum Ice Cube Tray:
I too purchased these because they reminded me of the ones we had when I was little. They came to me all dented and dinged. Was able to work those out butI tried everything to make them work, ran them under water, didn't fill them full and yet the handles still snapped off. Very disappointed in this product. Have purchased other items from Walter Drake and have enjoyed them so thought this item was safe to purchase as well. Really think they should be recalled and credits issued to the buyers. Need to provide stainless steel handles on these trays.
Bottom LineNo, I would not recommend this to a friend
Was this review helpful? Yes / No
- You may also flag this review
(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)
from Bakersfield, CA
I remember these ice trays as a kid, I liked them very much as a kid, and I really like the ones I got now.
Bottom LineYes, I would recommend this to a friend
(0 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
CHEAP CHEAP CHEAP
About Me Casual Cook
1st time I made ice with the tray the tray stuck to my hands an the handle bent. I tried different method to try and save the trays but there just to flimsy. Running water over the bottom of the tray got the ice and divider out but the handle still not strong enough to get ice out. My mom & dad had the old style of these and they lasted years, These did not last a mounth.
aluminun ice cube tray
By very dissatified
from Edina, MN
i likes the idea of the handle, but found out it was not very strong. i had a hard time getting the ice out of the trays. it was made really cheap. not stong at all.
By girl with dogs
from Pomona California
The first time I used these I didn't put much water in and when I pulled the ice out it almost bent the handle and the trays stick to my hands. The second time I went to use these I filled them up a little more and it was impossible to get them out without letting them sit out and melt a little. I am sending them back.
Know this product
By Busy Deb
(1 of 1 customers found this review helpful)
No greasy film like with plastic trays!
By unhappy customer
from st joseph mo
there were already dents in the unbelievably thin metal (?), not sure wouldn't break first time trying to release ice cubes -- definitely not worth the price
(3 of 3 customers found this review helpful)
Perfect Nostalgic Ice Tray that Works !
By Chef Alexandra
from San Jose, CA
About Me Gourmet Chef
Our ice machine broke in our refrig. I ordered these trays to make Ice Cubes until it's fixed. I grew up with this design. When they arrived it broght a smile to my face. After I filled them and the water froze, when I pulled back the lever, the Ice came out perfectly. I heard behind my back, "Cool !" it was my teenager daughter. What's not to love about that? ;)
These trays are like the old time trays. They don't break like plastic does. I love them!!